I need help with...

I need a larger recruiting team, where do I start

I Need A Larger Recruiting Team, Where Do I Start?

“Great vision without great people is irrelevant.” This quote is from Jim Collins, a renowned management professional. It highlights the paramount importance of recruiting the right talent. 


In the intricate tapestry of business success, one thread consistently stands out as crucial: the people. 


Imagine orchestrating a grand symphony with an undersized ensemble, or trying to paint a mural with only a handful of colors. That’s what it feels like running a thriving business with an inadequate recruiting team. With the corporate landscape becoming increasingly competitive, the hunt for top talent is not just about filling vacancies—it’s about securing the future of the company. 


This is why a robust and agile recruiting team is not just a luxury but a necessity. Just as a growing tree might need a larger pot or more fertile soil, there comes a point where a business needs to evaluate and possibly expand its recruiting team. Recognizing when this expansion becomes essential, and understanding the steps to take, is paramount. Dive in as we explore this vital aspect of organizational growth and discover the roadmap to expanding your recruiting team effectively.


But just like a plant outgrowing its pot, there will come a time when your recruiting team needs to grow to keep up with your company’s needs. How do you recognize that moment? And more importantly, where do you start? Keep reading this article to find the answers to these critical questions.


Recognizing the Need for a Larger Recruiting Team


In the fast-paced world of corporate growth, the need for a strong and capable recruiting team becomes more pronounced. But how do you discern the exact moment when expansion is not just beneficial but essential? Two main areas provide clear indicators: the evident signs that your recruitment process is overwhelmed and the evaluation of your team’s current performance.


When we speak of an overwhelmed recruitment process, one of the first indicators is an extended time-to-hire. If roles are staying vacant for longer than industry standards, this could signify that the team is unable to manage the hiring load effectively. Coupled with this, a noticeable backlog of unprocessed applications often emerges. Like letters piling up in an unattended mailbox, these applications become stark symbols of a team that’s struggling to keep up.


Moreover, while quantity can be a concern, quality shouldn’t be compromised either. A dip in the quality of new hires, reflected in their skills or their cultural alignment with the company, can sometimes be the consequence of a recruitment team that doesn’t have the time or resources to adequately screen candidates. This can be further magnified when the recruitment team is consistently buried under work, burning the midnight oil, and missing out on critical recruitment events and opportunities.


Evaluating team performance goes beyond just looking at outcomes; it delves into the intricacies of the process. Regular feedback from hiring managers can offer insights into whether they are satisfied with the candidates they interview and eventually hire. Candidates themselves provide a valuable perspective. If the candidate experience starts to deteriorate—marked by feelings of being neglected or facing a convoluted hiring process—it often points to a recruitment team stretched too thin. 


Furthermore, when newly hired employees leave within their first year, it might be a reflection of rushed hiring decisions made by an overwhelmed team. 


Finally, in this age of digital transformation, if your team isn’t leveraging the latest recruiting technologies or tools effectively, it might be because they’re too swamped to adapt, signaling an urgent need for expansion.


Steps to Begin the Expansion Process


Embarking on the journey of expanding your recruiting team is akin to setting the foundations for a new chapter of growth. It’s imperative to approach this with a clear strategy and vision. Central to this vision is the identification of roles and their distribution within the team.


Role identification goes beyond merely listing job titles; it’s about understanding the core functions and responsibilities that need to be addressed for the team to function optimally. For instance, if your recruitment process is lacking in sourcing top talent, then perhaps a role focused exclusively on this is warranted. 


Or, if your onboarding process seems rushed, a position dedicated to candidate engagement and integration might be the solution. By identifying these gaps and creating roles tailored to fill them, you not only streamline the recruitment process but also ensure that each team member has a clear and defined purpose.


Then comes the pivotal decision: should you promote from within or bring in fresh faces? Both routes have their merits. Internal promotions can be a powerful motivator, demonstrating to your current team that hard work and dedication are rewarded. It also ensures that the promoted individual already understands company culture and processes, ensuring a smoother transition. 


On the other hand, new hires bring with them fresh perspectives, new skills, and possibly, expertise that the current team might lack. They can be catalysts for innovation and change, shaking things up in just the right ways. The choice often boils down to the specific needs of the company and the gaps you’re trying to fill. A balanced approach, promoting internal talent while also injecting new energy with external hires, often yields the best results.


Recognizing the need for a larger recruiting team and then navigating the expansion process requires a delicate balance of introspection, strategy, and vision. As the corporate landscape continues to evolve, ensuring that your recruiting team grows and adapts in tandem becomes not just beneficial but vital for sustained success.


Challenges in the Expansion Journey


Expanding a recruiting team is akin to navigating a dense forest. While the promise of reaching a clearing teeming with opportunities is exciting, the path can often be winding and fraught with obstacles.


One of the most common challenges organizations face during such expansions is hasty hiring. Eager to grow, companies may speed up their recruitment processes, sometimes leading to choices that don’t fully align with their needs. This urgency can also lead to inadequate role definitions. Without a clear demarcation of responsibilities, overlaps and ambiguities can creep in, disrupting smooth operations.


Equally challenging is the preservation of company culture. As new members join the fold, there’s an ever-present risk of diluting the very ethos that made the organization unique in the first place. Moreover, financial strains are a real concern. Expansion, while necessary, requires resources. Moving too quickly without strategic financial planning can end up being a costly affair.


Lastly, the human factor comes into play. Existing members of the team might resist change. They might view expansion with a hint of skepticism, concerned about their own roles in the evolving landscape.


However, every challenge comes with a solution waiting to be discovered. To counter hasty hiring, adopting a methodical and structured recruitment approach ensures that quality isn’t sacrificed for speed. Clear communication can be the antidote to role ambiguities. Engaging team meetings and frequent check-ins can help in setting clear expectations.


To ensure that the unique company culture remains intact, introducing orientation sessions for new hires and fostering mentorship programs can make a world of difference. As for financial concerns, meticulous budgeting, taking into account both immediate and long-term expenses, can pave the way for sustainable expansion.


Change is always daunting, but with transparent communication, emphasizing the vision, and ensuring everyone feels valued, you will make the transition smoother.


Tools and Techniques for a Smooth Transition


In the realm of recruiting, the digital age has ushered in a plethora of platforms that promise to streamline processes. Platforms like LinkedIn Recruiter, tapping into a vast reservoir of professionals, or tools like Workable and Greenhouse, which offer comprehensive recruitment solutions, have become indispensable. Then there’s Bullhorn, a favorite among many recruitment agencies, known for its effective CRM and operations software.


These platforms are not just about automation; they’re about enhancing the very fabric of recruitment. They save invaluable time, minimize human errors, and provide deep insights into the recruitment landscape. Their essence lies in enabling recruiters to shift their focus from mundane tasks to truly understanding and connecting with potential hires.


Training, on the other hand, goes beyond mere skill enhancement. It’s the bridge that connects old and new, ensuring seamless integration of new members into the team. Training sessions, especially when done collectively, become platforms for knowledge sharing and foster a sense of camaraderie. They ensure that everyone, irrespective of their tenure, is updated on the latest industry trends, tools, and best practices. More than just imparting knowledge, training becomes a conduit for team cohesion, helping everyone work in harmony.


In essence, the journey of expanding a recruiting team, while challenging, is a transformative one. With the right strategies, tools, and an emphasis on continuous learning and adaptation, it’s a journey that promises growth, not just in numbers but in potential and vision.


Managing the New, Larger Team


Scaling up your recruiting team is just the first step; managing this expanded team efficiently is the next significant challenge. A larger team brings with it the intricacies of diverse opinions, strengths, and areas for improvement. Central to this successful management is ensuring a seamless flow of communication. 


Communication isn’t merely about relaying information; it’s about creating an environment where team members feel heard, understood, and valued.


Effective communication strategies involve consistent touchpoints, open channels, and platforms that foster collaboration. Encourage team members to share their insights, ideas, and even concerns in regular team meetings. These platforms should promote not just vertical communication—between leadership and team members—but also horizontal communication among peers. This ensures that everyone remains on the same page, avoiding misunderstandings and promoting cohesion.


However, communication is a two-way street. As much as it’s essential for leadership and managers to relay directives and share visions, it’s equally vital for them to listen. This brings us to the importance of feedback and regular check-ins. 


Regular check-ins, whether formal or informal, can act as a pulse check, giving insights into the team’s morale, challenges faced, and even possible innovations. Feedback, when delivered constructively, acts as a growth tool, helping team members understand areas of improvement and how they can excel. Simultaneously, encouraging team members to provide feedback about the processes, tools, or even leadership can provide invaluable insights to ensure the recruiting team’s optimal functioning.




As we journey through the nuances of recognizing the need for an expanded recruiting team to managing this new team efficiently, one thing remains clear: a well-equipped recruiting team is the backbone of any thriving organization. They are the gatekeepers, ensuring that your company is fueled by talent that doesn’t just meet current needs but also anticipates future challenges.


For businesses looking to scale, adapt, and stay ahead of the curve, taking the steps outlined in this article isn’t just an option; it’s a necessity. These strategies and insights act as a compass, guiding you through the complexities of team expansion and ensuring that the process, from recognition to management, is as seamless and efficient as possible.


To all our readers, remember that each organization is unique, and while these guidelines provide a roadmap, it’s the unique attributes of your company that will define its journey. Should you have more questions, you should contact us and we will get back to you shortly.


Your success is our mission, and together, we can forge the path to a brighter, talent-rich future.

Picture of Natalie Bollinger

Natalie Bollinger

View All Posts

I need help with...

Stay Up to Date with Industry Insights